Lord Of The Rings: War In The North Legacy Edition review: A competent orc-slicing adventure | Daily Reports Online
Why you can trust TechRadar
We spend hours testing every product or service we review, so you can be sure you’re buying the best. Find out more about how we test.
The Lord Of The Rings: War In The North Legacy Edition (henceforth known as WITN) is a new version of the old action role-playing game (RPG) with a few quality-of-life fixes, tweaks, and improvements.
It ends up being diverting fun and well-priced for what it is, and gamers who loved the original (or perhaps loved games like it, such as Dragon Age: Origins) will enjoy the return to this sort of simple-but-satisfying gameplay loop of hitting orcs, looting gear, and upgrading your characters so they can hit orcs harder, faster, and for longer without falling over.
Review info
Platform reviewed: Nintendo Switch
Available on: PS5, Xbox Series X, Xbox Series S, PC, Nintendo Switch 2, Nintendo Switch
Release date: 11 August (PS5, Xbox, PC), 18 August (Nintendo)
But while much of the game is fine, if not spectacular, it’s a shame there are a few technical problems and deeper issues. Swapping between characters on-the-fly is novel, and there has been an effort to incorporate this into all aspects of gameplay. However, hot-swapping is obviously not quite what the original game intended, so there is some awkwardness here, while glitches and bugs sometimes mar the game at key points.
Latest Videos FromTechRadar
What about second Fellowship?
If you never played the old version, the basis of the game is this: as the Fellowship of the Ring embarks on their quest for Mount Doom, you play an adjacent, original party consisting of Eradan, a Dunedain ranger with all the skills of Aragorn; Farin, a dwarf warrior from the Lonely Mountain who looks an awful lot like Gimli with the serial numbers filed off; and Andriel, a Loremaster elf from Rivendell who can create magical blasts and forcefields.
Together, the ‘other’ Fellowship party chats with old friends like Aragorn, Arwen and Gandalf, visits familiar and new locations (book-readers will get a kick out of delving into the Barrow-Downs and fighting the famous Wights), and slices through hordes of orcs led by an evil man called Agandaûr, a fallen Numenorean like the Mouth of Sauron. Agandaûr is one of Sauron’s trusted servants, one we’ve never heard of before or since.
So yes, it’s all a bit fan-fictionesque, and it plays a lot like other action RPGs set in fantasy worlds, only this one takes the basic fantasy character set and plops them straight into Middle-Earth rather than a parallel-but-similar setting of elves, dwarves and dragons. It’s even funnier when you get hold of special character weapon options, and you’re controlling a random dwarf running around with legendary gear like Anduril or Sting. Dedicated Tolkien enthusiasts might find it a bit egregious, but it’s all in the name of good fun and enabling the sort of repetitive hack-and-slash gameplay the genre is best at.
If you’ve played any other Lord Of The Rings games, whether the PlayStation 2’s Return of the King or a more recent title like Middle-earth: Shadow of War, you’ll be used to LOTR games taking these sorts of creative liberties. As a result, it works for what it is, and even as a die-hard hobbit-enjoyer I had fun scything through the dark lord’s evil hordes and meeting characters never adapted like Elladan and Elrohir, Elrond’s twin ranger sons.
Old game, new tactics
If you’ve played any action RPG, you’ll know what to expect: you and your party are taking on wave after wave of mooks, weapons swinging with basic attacks, but you’ll also trigger powerful maneuvers and spells that require cooldowns and replenishing a power meter, so tactical implementation of these moves is vital. Playing as Eradan, I would be skirting low on health and could use my disappearing skill, so I could make a break for it unharmed to Andriel’s side, who can create a protective healing field. I’d quickly swap to Farin to unleash War Cry to up my party’s health and durability.
It’s this sort of synergy that creates tactical play beyond mashing light and heavy attacks until you see the ‘Finish Him!’ yellow triangle that pops up over an enemy’s head. The ability to swap characters allows the quick-of-thumb to set up these combos without the use of the AI characters, who are otherwise competent enough to look after themselves and augment the main player. But you do need to be nimble, as the controls to do this are awkward on Switch: even ten hours in, I was accidentally drinking potions when I was trying to swap from elf to dwarf. Co-operative gameplay is available on most platforms (both online, in which you drop into someone else’s game, and couch), but not on the original Switch.
There’s a surprisingly steep learning curve once you learn the ropes: enemies come from all sides thick and fast, in numerous varieties, forcing you to switch from attack to defence, and then to ranged as explosive enemies approach, and implement your powers carefully.
You level up quickly too, and loot is plentiful, so there are plenty of regular rewards encouraging you to persevere through the samey waves of orcs and goblins, as PCs, enemies and environments begin to blend into various overlapping shades of brown and grey. I began the game thinking carefully about upgrading stats at each level, but after a while, I just pumped Stamina to keep myself alive while concentrating on that character’s main attack stat, and that strategy seemed to work just fine too. I’m honestly not sure how much difference these RPG elements made.
Feeling thin, sort of stretched…
While a simple-but-satisfying gameplay loop, it’s still very much of its time, and parts haven’t aged well. The target lock-on can get tricky, and you’ll occasionally find your character engaged in a long, sluggish animation, swinging their weapon at empty air while you cringe as you watch orcs running at you from behind.
Despite the hot-swapping feature and inclusion of each character’s unique secret-finding ability (the dwarf, for example, can detect treasure hidden behind stone walls), the game is clearly still geared for a single-character experience. Ammo drops are still linked to the character you’re playing at the time, so you might find you swap to a character without any ranged capacity. You’ll also need to visit shops with each character in turn to do a proper gear comparison before buying new equipment, which is tedious.
Your health and power replenish slowly on their own, but once you’ve cleared an encounter, you’re under no pressure to carry on. Occasionally, I found myself putting the controller down unpaused, heading off to make a cup of tea, and returning with my beverage to a rested, unmolested party at full health.
There’s no sheathing weapons, so you’ll occasionally be wandering around Bree or Rivendell, incongruously with swords drawn ready for action. There’s also no jumping, which is fine on its own, but the frustration of encountering a chest-high wall and having to find a set of stairs is a sensation I’ve almost forgotten about, a relic of level design marred by the technology of the time.
Worst of all are the bugs, Aspyr’s revamp of the game delivering fresh technical glitches alongside the improvements. These are quite common complaints on threads about WITN, and my experience was no different: from flashing inventory tiles to small areas of the map that caused my entire screen to flip to solid green. At one stage I was fighting blind, looking at chequered green flashes, while I could still hear Eradan’s shouts of ‘You face a Dunedan now!’
Others report platform-specific glitches, such as an 0KB save file problem on PlayStation 5.
The North Remembers
I think you already know if you want this game: you’re either a Tolkien fiend who likes the idea of exploring and interacting with lesser-known locations and characters in an original story, a fantasy action RPG junkie, or you played the original and remember loving it. At the reduced price it’s selling for, it’s worth getting if you fit two out of three of the above criteria.
Personally, even though I’m as Tolkien-mad as they come and I’ve got no shortage of love for the RPG genre, I think The Lord Of The Rings: War In The North Legacy Edition is… fine. Serviceable. Enjoyable at times, but without much to set it apart from all the other games in the space, even back when it was first released, other than its LOTR wrapper and nostalgia goggles.
I liked my experience with the game, but I can’t see myself going back to it once done. It’s a poor man’s bite of lembas compared to the previous generation’s excellent Return of the King hack ’em up.
Should you play The Lord Of The Rings: War In The North Legacy Edition?
Play it if…
Don’t play it if…
How I reviewed Lord of the Rings: War In The North Legacy Edition
I played Lord Of The Rings: War In The North Legacy Edition on my Nintendo Switch (generation 1) for 15 hours, trying each character’s various combinations and progressing through the story mode. I used the Switch both in handheld mode and on my LG OLED TV. When I encountered glitches, I examined community pages and threads for similar reports.
First reviewed August 2026
